
Summary: Marketplaces bring a ready audience and quick sales, but charge commissions and fees, put you side by side with competitors and limit your relationship with customers. Your own store requires investing in promotion, but gives you control of brand, price, experience and data to sell again. For many businesses, the best approach is to combine both, with different roles.
This is one of the conversations we have most with people who want to sell online. The honest answer: it depends on the business's stage, margin and ability to invest in customer acquisition.
The upside of marketplaces
- Ready audience: people are already there with purchase intent.
- Borrowed trust: buyers trust the platform even if they don't know you.
- Integrated logistics and payments in many cases.
- Quick testing of product and price.
What marketplaces charge (beyond commission)
- Fees: per-sale commission, fixed fees, subsidized or mandatory shipping, internal ads to gain visibility. Amounts change frequently and vary by category: always check each platform's official fee table.
- Price wars: your product appears next to competitors' and the decision tends to come down to price.
- Limited relationship: platforms restrict direct contact and use of buyer data outside them.
- Changing rules: policies, fees and exposure algorithms can change, and you adapt.
- Account risk: reputation and suspensions depend on the platform's metrics and rules.
The upside of your own store
- Brand, storefront, price and experience under your control.
- Coupons, bundles, free shipping above a threshold, loyalty programs.
- Your own customer base (with consent under data protection laws) for email, WhatsApp and retargeting.
- Margin tends to be higher, with no intermediary commission.
The challenge of your own store
Nobody stumbles onto a new store by chance. It needs traffic: Google Ads (including Shopping, which uses the Merchant Center product feed), Instagram ads, SEO for category and product pages, email and social media. The cost of acquiring each customer goes into the calculation.
Do the margin math
Sale price: R$ 200.00
Product cost: − R$ 90.00
Taxes (e.g., 6%): − R$ 12.00
Marketplace: commission and fees (e.g.) − R$ 30.00
Subsidized shipping (e.g.) − R$ 10.00
Marketplace margin: R$ 58.00
Own store: payment fee (e.g.) − R$ 8.00
Acquisition cost per order (e.g.) − R$ 35.00
Own store margin: R$ 55.00 (on the first order)
The numbers are illustrative only: use each channel's real fees and your measured acquisition cost. Note that, in your own store, a repeat purchase doesn't pay a new acquisition cost if the customer comes back via email or WhatsApp. That's usually where your own store wins.
So, which to choose?
- Starting out, with little cash: a marketplace to validate product and price.
- With a brand and repeat purchases: your own store as the main channel.
- The most common path: both. The marketplace generates volume and cash; your own store builds brand, margin and customer base.
We detail every cost in how much an online store costs. If you want your own, the starting point is a well-built online store: fast, with local payment methods and cards, shipping calculation, good on mobile, a clear returns policy and built to appear on Google. There's no point investing in ads to send customers to a store that freezes at checkout.
Sources and references
- Brazil: Decree 7,962/2013 (e-commerce)
- Brazil's Consumer Protection Code (right of withdrawal, art. 49)
- Google Merchant Center: introduction
- Google Search Central: SEO for ecommerce
Frequently asked questions
Can I sell on a marketplace and my own store at the same time?
Yes, it's the most common path. Keep inventory synchronized and prices consistent across channels.
Can I bring marketplace customers to my store?
Platforms usually prohibit direct contact and use of buyer data for that. Read each platform's rules to avoid account suspension.
Does my own store need to follow specific laws?
Yes. In Brazil, Decree 7,962/2013 requires clear information about the company, price, conditions and customer service, and the Consumer Protection Code guarantees a 7-day right of withdrawal. Other countries have their own consumer rules.
How does my own store appear on Google Shopping?
By submitting the catalog to Google Merchant Center, which enables free listings and Shopping ads.
Ready for your own online store?
We build complete, fast online stores ready to sell and rank on Google.
Read also
- How much does an online store cost?
- How much does it cost to advertise on Google Ads?
- How much does it cost to advertise on Instagram?
Written by Mário Moreno, founder of Agência hetsi, which has been building websites and handling digital marketing for businesses in Brazil and abroad since 2000. Mário Moreno on LinkedIn